Dylan Moore and Theodora Day are busy going through neckties when Coal Daniels walks in on them. He asks what they're doing and Dylan says since her mom is gone the girls thought they could help him out. The girls talk about all the fun things they can do with ties like tying someone up or blindfolding them, but Coal declines to have them demonstrate.
The next day, Theodora and Dylan take all of Coal's ties and hide them with the exception of the one they're each wearing. This time, they won't take no for an answer when it comes to sharing everything with Dylan's stepdaddy. Opening their shirts to bare their small titties, the girls exchange kisses and then get into bed so Coal can sample the flavor of each creamy pussy.
The girls return the favor with a double BJ to whet Coal's appetite. Stepdaddy finally gets some as Dylan mounts him for a reverse cowgirl ride. He gives Theodora a pussy pounding as she lays on her back, then flips her onto her knees so she can enjoy his dick in doggy while she eats Dylan out. Dylan finishes their threesum off in the middle as Coal fucks her to a creampie while Theodora rides her face. Spent, the girls remind Coal he can never tell.