Valentine's Day is coming up and someone is leaving secret admirer cards for Damon Dice. He goes to confront his step-cousin, stepsister, and adopted sister to see if they know what's up. Jane Wilde, Jessie Saint, and Mackenzie Moss all deny knowing anything about it. When Damon leaves, Jane, the step-cousin, confesses that she gave him one of the cards after giving him a striptease to allegedly ask his opinion of some Valentine's lingerie. Next, Jessie admits that she left him a card after offering to give him a naked back massage. Finally, Mackenzie admits that she snuck into Damon's room, naked, and covered herself in flower petals while leaving a card. Too bad none of the girls' stories match up with the reality of what happened.

Damon returns to tell the girls that he can't figure out who sent the cards. He tells them that he can't figure out who sent the cards and that it's too bad because he had big plans for whomever it may have been. The girls say they'll be right back and then run off to change into a trio of Valentine's lingerie getups. Returning, they insist that Damon keep his word that he fuck the mystery card sender by fucking all three of them. As they pop Damon's dick out to start sucking, they ask him whose card he liked best. Damon won't answer, despite their best efforts as the girls take turns swallowing his cock.

Jane eventually sits down backwards on Damon's hardon for the first ride. Mackenzie gets the next ride, but then Jessie leans over the table so Damon can switch things up and bang her from behind. Getting creative, Mackenzie hops on the table so Jessie can eat her out as Damon fucks her. Jane copies Jessie's position as Jessie simply kneels to keep eating Mackenzie out. Then Mackenzie follows suit as Jessie fondles Jane's pussy. The girls then all get on the table, where they sit side by side and link legs so that Damon can enjoy their pussy buffet. Jane gets the D first, followed once again by Mackenzie and then Jessie. By the time Jessie's turn comes around, Damon is primed to cum! He blows his load inside Jessie, giving her a creampie that drips down to the ground.